Dear Mr. Fitzgerald,
I have a bone to pick with you. Stop smiling.
Alright, first and foremost, I finished your book yesterday, The Beautiful and the Damned. I really wanted to like it, because there's something about you that I like. You're such a goddamn tragic figure who had a ridiculously large number of insecurities and self destructive tendencies and romantic visions of the world.... I mean, I wouldn't want to have been friends with you or anything; you would have driven me completely up the wall. But there was something engaging about you regardless which came through your letters in Dangerous Friendship: Fitzgerald and Hemingway. You were immensely flawed, but that may have been what made you so likable. You were fascinating.
Unfortunately, I'm having problems with the extension of that same tolerance for juxtaposition to your work.
When Virginia Woolf and I undertook the rereading Great Gatsby last week, we were mildly alarmed to discover just how empty that novel was. I mean, it's not like stuff doesn't happen, given that one person gets run over by a car, one is bewildered by real books, and another gets shot in a pool because he's completely spineless and disillusioned and lies and cheats and rowed a boat and really didn't understand the intricate workings of that crazy thing we call reality and gee golly I'm pretty sure that was meant to be you, but despite the volume of things happening in a relatively short book, it's just... empty. Woolf and I came to the conclusion that the emptiness was, of course, purposeful in that it was meant to reflect both the temporal 20's as well as the age strictures, and we were able to draw out distinct tangles and pinpoints that, once our conversation concluded, allowed us to pull together an overall interpretation of your work that left us feeling better than we had at the outset.
Beautiful and the Damned? Not so much.
Woolf has not read that one - it was my own undertaking because I was determined to discover that the mess you called This Side of Paradise was only a one time, completely irritating piece of melodramatic nonsense. I'd really hoped that B&D would show a greater sense of purpose in the writing, less time wasted rolling around through inner ramblings and justifications that didn't particularly ingratiate me to your characters, let alone you. But B&D was just really freaking aggravating. I didn't like any of the characters, mainly because they were all morons. However, where I'm getting the impression in the even more melodramatic work The Good Soldier by Ford Madox Ford that I'm actually supposed to dislike his characters because they are all morons, I'm not entirely certain that you intended for me to find your characters moronic. But they are. They are completely moronic. I felt that, even though Anthony proves himself to be the laziest, most self absorbed and egotistical child on the planet by the end, you still wanted me to pity him. Pity him! I wanted to throw him under a bus!
Really, Fitzgerald. What were you doing?
And don't get me started on Gloria. I find it very hard to engage with characters where the only one who displays any amount of intelligence keeps getting described as looking like "a large cat" and "a tiger" and who sits on top of a railway station watching the sun come up after describing at length why he doesn't actually think the world means anything. FITZGERALD. WE'VE BEEN THROUGH THIS. Why did I read TSOP if you were going to tell me the same thing in a book with a much nicer cover some years later? And why the hell is it over 300 pages?! Nothing actually happens! They date, they get married, he goes off to war and she's told she's too old to play an ingenue, and then they stop loving each other and life is meaningless. WHY DID THAT TAKE 322 PAGES, FITZGERALD?
WHY
WHY
WHY
Oh, stop looking at me like that. You're a goddamn literary icon - what do you care about the fact that some of your writing makes me want to bang the book against my head repeatedly until my vision spaces out and suddenly everything seems interesting again? And I'm not saying ALL your writing is like this, anyway. I just told you that Woolf and I redeemed Gatsby together (though Flannery O claims that Daisy isn't a selfish moronic ditz, but I think Flannery probably needs to stop drinking), and I actually do like your stories in Tales of the Jazz Age. Plus, I haven't even told you yet that Leviticus (or was it St. John?) and I are going to a library book sale on Saturday and I plan on finding some more of your work if I can. I'm going to try Tender is the Night, Fitzgerald. Last attempt. Don't make me regret it, because I absolutely refuse to read The Love of the Last Tycoon. Nobody cares about tycoons unless we're talking about the guy who gets you out of jail free in Monopoly. Just saying.
So you have one final chance, Fitzgerald. You'd better not have screwed up it.... when you wrote it about a century ago..........
You were warned.
Regards,
The Bird.











